Is Barrell Bourbon Really Worth the Hype?

Explore the story behind Barrell Bourbon, analyze what sets it apart, and determine if it's worth the hype. Is it a worthy addition to your bar cart or just another marketing gimmick? The verdict may surprise you.

You’ve probably noticed those slick bottles catching your eye at the liquor store. Barrell Bourbon seems to be everywhere these days, flaunting its fancy packaging and those premium prices. But the big question is: does this craft spirit truly live up to the buzz, or is it just clever marketing trying to win over bourbon newbies? Before you shell out $80 or more on a bottle of Barrell, you owe it to yourself to really understand what’s inside and whether it delivers on its promises. So, grab a glass, and over the next few minutes, we’ll dive into the story behind Barrell Bourbon, break down what makes their bourbon blends stand out, and settle the debate once and for all: is this a premium bourbon that deserves a spot of honor on your bar cart, or should it stay on the shelf? Trust me, the answer might just surprise you.

What Exactly Is Barrell Bourbon?

Think of Barrell Bourbon as a master curator of bourbon. They’re an independent bottler who sources exceptional bourbon barrels from distilleries across Kentucky and Tennessee. Unlike most distilleries that handle everything from mashing grains to bottling, Barrell focuses on finding already-aged bourbon and expertly blending those barrels to create their own unique and exciting expressions.

Right now, Barrell offers a range of different bourbon blends, spanning from a respectable 4 years all the way up to a mature 24 years old. Because they hand-select barrels from various distilleries, each blend boasts its own distinct flavor profile. Take their flagship Barrell Bourbon batch 001, for instance. It’s a thoughtful marriage of 9 to 15-year-old bourbons, resulting in a complex, oaky character with delicious hints of dried fruit and spice. On the other hand, their 24-year-old blend really showcases the sweeter, nuttier notes that can develop in older bourbons.

While it’s true that Barrell’s bourbons come with a steeper price tag, many seasoned whiskey aficionados believe that the premium is justified by the chance to experience such a diverse collection of aged bourbons side by side. Barrell also loves to keep things interesting with frequent releases of experimental and limited edition blends, giving us bourbon lovers the opportunity to discover truly new and intriguing flavors.

So, if you’re curious to explore the incredible spectrum of flavors that bourbon can offer, or if you’re on the hunt for a special bottle to elevate your collection, Barrell Bourbon has a lot to get excited about. Their innovative approach to blending and their knack for finding rare, well-aged bourbons have earned Barrell a dedicated following and a respected place in the bourbon world.

The Story Behind the Brand

Barrell Craft Spirits came onto the scene in 2013 with a mission: to create premium aged bourbons and ryes. They’re known for sourcing high-quality distillate, often from distilleries like MGP, and then they take charge of the aging, blending, and bottling process themselves.

Here’s a bit more about what makes them tick:

  • Extended Aging: Barrell often ages their bourbons longer than what you typically see, frequently going beyond the 5-year mark. This patient approach allows for more intricate and distinctive flavors to develop compared to younger bourbons.
  • Small Batch, Unique Releases: They focus on small batch, limited releases, which means each batch can have its own subtle nuances. This keeps things exciting, offering the chance to taste new and unique flavors with every bottle.
  • Transparency Matters: Barrell is pretty open about where they source their distillate and how long it’s been aged. For us bourbon aficionados, knowing exactly what’s in the bottle is a big plus.
  • The Art of Blending, Not Distilling: They don’t operate their own distillery. Instead, their expertise lies in the art of blending and careful aging. This allows them to craft bourbons and ryes with a fascinating variety of mash bills and age profiles.
  • Worth the Investment: While Barrell bourbon does command a premium price, their dedication to quality and craftsmanship results in a spirit that’s truly worth savoring. For bourbon lovers seeking something new, memorable, and undeniably premium, Barrell is a brand that lives up to the hype.

Barrell Bourbon’s Unique Blending Process

What truly sets Barrell Craft Spirits apart is their thoughtfully developed blending technique.

They meticulously source bourbon from Kentucky, Tennessee, and Indiana, selecting barrels ranging from 4 to 15 years old. But here’s where the magic happens: instead of simply bottling bourbon from a single distillery, Barrell’s master blenders skillfully combine bourbons of different ages and recipes to create a harmonious and complex tapestry of flavor.

This meticulous blending process empowers them to craft bourbon with a distinct flavor profile each and every time. In fact, no two batches are exactly alike, so every bottle you pick up promises a unique tasting adventure. This blending method also gives them the ability to fine-tune the bourbon, achieving an ideal balance of sweet and spicy notes or hitting a very specific flavor target they have in mind.

Now, some purists might argue that blending can mask the individual character of each bourbon component. However, Barrell’s blending technique really shines a light on the skill of their master blenders, showcasing their ability to coax out and then artfully combine the best qualities of multiple bourbons into an innovative new creation. For bourbon aficionados on the hunt for a truly unique and artisanal spirit, Barrell’s blended bourbons offer an exciting new world to explore.

Ultimately, this innovative blending process is the heart and soul of Barrell bourbon’s signature taste and identity. This less traditional approach has cultivated a loyal following for Barrell and cemented their reputation as one of the most forward-thinking new players in the bourbon scene. If you’re intrigued by the idea of experiencing bourbon in a completely fresh way, Barrell’s blended bourbons are absolutely worth seeking out.

What Makes Barrell Bourbon Special?

Barrell Bourbon isn’t your run-of-the-mill Kentucky bourbon. Its uniqueness stems from its distinctive aging and blending process. The folks at Barrell source bourbon from various distilleries across Kentucky, and then they age each selection separately in a diverse range of barrel types. Think beyond just new charred oak – they also utilize once-used barrels, as well as barrels that have been toasted and charred in specific ways.

Once these bourbons have reached their peak, the distillers expertly blend different selections together to create intricate flavors that you simply won’t find in a single-distillery bottling. The result is a smooth, well-balanced bourbon that unfolds in layers of flavor with every sip, revealing notes of vanilla, spice, citrus, and caramel. If you’re on the lookout for an innovative and flavorful bourbon bottled at cask strength, Barrell is an excellent choice.

Of course, this level of innovation comes with a higher price point. Barrell Bourbon typically ranges from $70 to $90 per bottle, depending on the specific batch. While it’s certainly not the cheapest option, for serious bourbon connoisseurs and those seeking a truly premium sipping experience, the splurge can be well worth it. The sheer variety of flavors and the undeniable artistry of the blending are truly something special.

Now, for the bourbon traditionalists out there, Barrell’s less conventional aging and blending process might feel a bit too progressive. Also, the specific distilleries of origin for the bourbons used are not disclosed, so you never quite know the exact recipe from one batch to the next. However, if you’re open to experiencing bourbon in a whole new light, Barrell delivers a unique and compelling product that’s really pushing the boundaries of the craft bourbon movement.

Reviews of Top Barrell Bourbon Expressions

Judging by the reviews, the buzz around Barrell Bourbon is definitely justified. Their small batch bourbons are crafted with a diverse range of mash bills and aging techniques, consistently delivering complex and unique flavors.

  • Barrell Batch 021: This intriguing blend of 6, 7, and 8-year-old bourbons hailing from Indiana, Kentucky, and Tennessee is often described as having delightful notes of “dark sweets, oak char, and pepper.” Reviewers frequently commend its excellent balance of sweet and spicy elements, all leading to a satisfyingly smooth finish.
  • Barrell Dovetail: Aged for up to 9 years, Dovetail is a fascinating combination of straight bourbons and whiskeys that have been finished in rum, port, and cabernet barrels. Expect to find enticing notes of “fruitcake, maple, and orange peel.” Critics often hail it as innovative, remarkably complex, and one of the finest finished whiskeys available.
  • Barrell Armida: This unique bourbon undergoes a double barrel finish in armagnac and pear brandy casks. Aged for up to 9 years, it offers distinctive flavors of “poached pears, nut bread, and cinnamon.” Reviewers rave about the sweet and fruity character that this unusual finishing process imparts, making it unlike any other bourbon out there.

While it’s true that Barrell’s bourbons come with a higher price tag, many discerning whiskey aficionados believe that the exceptional quality, impressive depth of flavor, and overall innovation make them well worth the investment. Barrell is consistently producing some of the most interesting and best-tasting craft bourbons on the market today. If you’re seeking an extraordinary sipping experience, Barrell Bourbon should definitely be on your must-try list.

How Barrell Compares to Other Popular Bourbons

Barrell craft spirits are known for their small batch production and artful aging, but how do they stack up against other well-known bourbon brands? When you compare them to more mainstream bourbons like Jim Beam, Maker’s Mark, or Buffalo Trace, Barrell bourbons tend to exhibit a greater complexity of flavor, often showcasing spicier and fruitier notes. However, this elevated experience comes with a higher price tag, largely due to their smaller production scale and longer aging periods.

If you consider yourself a bourbon aficionado in search of a premium sipping experience, then Barrell bourbons are definitely worth the splurge. Their unique aging and blending techniques result in bourbons that are bursting with rich flavors, such as dried cherries, toasted nuts, and warm baking spices. Each batch offers a new and exciting tasting journey. On the other hand, if you’re a more casual bourbon drinker or keeping an eye on your budget, you might find Barrell’s offerings to be a bit too niche or expensive. In that case, sticking with a more affordable and versatile option from a larger distillery might be a better fit.

Ultimately, deciding whether Barrell bourbon is worth the hype boils down to your personal preferences and how much you’re willing to spend. While Barrell undoubtedly crafts an exceptional product within the premium bourbon category, their commitment to small-batch production and high quality means you’ll be paying a premium per bottle. If complex, almost dessert-like bourbon flavors and a truly memorable drinking experience are your top priorities, then Barrell bourbon absolutely deserves a place on your bar cart. However, for a reliable daily sipper that won’t break the bank, other brands might be a more practical choice. The final verdict? It’s all about what you value in a bourbon!

Is Barrell Worth the Price Tag?

Barrell Bourbon is undeniably a premium craft bourbon, and it comes with a price tag to match. You’ll typically find their bottles starting around $80 and going upwards of $250 or even more for their rarer, older expressions. So, the big question remains: is Barrell Bourbon truly worth the hype and the significant cost?

For many dedicated bourbon connoisseurs, Barrell delivers an unparalleled tasting experience that fully justifies the investment. They meticulously source high-quality bourbon from Kentucky, Tennessee, and Indiana, and then they expertly blend and finish these selections to create complex and nuanced flavors that you simply won’t encounter in any other bottle. Expressions like Dovetail, Seagrass, and Armida are prime examples of their masterful blending and aging techniques. The end results are sophisticated, layered pours that continue to evolve with each sip.

However, let’s be honest, $100 or more for a single bottle of bourbon is a considerable expense. If you’re relatively new to the world of bourbon or you’re mindful of your budget, Barrell might not be the ideal starting point. Their bourbons are crafted with discerning palates in mind, and some of the subtle nuances might be lost on less experienced drinkers. You’re also, to some extent, paying a premium for the brand’s reputation and the overall buzz surrounding it, in addition to the liquid itself.

For most people, Barrell is likely to be an occasional indulgence, a special treat for those moments when you want something truly exceptional. But if your goal is to experience the pinnacle of craft bourbon, Barrell delivers an unmatched product that lives up to its prestigious reputation and price. Ultimately, the decision rests on you – how much is that extraordinary experience worth to your palate and your wallet? For serious bourbon connoisseurs seeking the absolute finest sip, Barrell Bourbon is undoubtedly a worthwhile investment.

Where to Buy Barrell Bourbon

Barrell Bourbon is highly sought after by whiskey aficionados, but unfortunately, its limited production can sometimes make it a bit of a challenge to find. Here are some strategies to help you track down a bottle of this prized spirit:

  • The Distillery: The Barrell Craft Spirits distillery is located in Louisville, Kentucky. They often offer free tours and tastings, and bottles are frequently available for purchase directly on-site. If you happen to be in the area, this is your best bet for acquiring Barrell Bourbon straight from the source.
  • Online Retailers: Several online liquor stores that offer nationwide shipping may occasionally have Barrell Bourbon in stock on their websites, available for purchase and delivery to many states. Keep an eye on sites like Caskers, ReserveBar, and Astor Wines, and be ready to act quickly, as their inventory tends to sell out rapidly.
  • Secondary Markets: If the distillery and major retailers are sold out, you might need to explore the secondary market. Websites like Wine-Searcher, 1000 Corks, and Bottle Blue Book can help you find private sellers and smaller liquor stores that may still have Barrell Bourbon available. However, be prepared to pay a premium, often significantly higher than the standard retail price.
  • Patience and Persistence: The significant demand for Barrell Bourbon, coupled with its small-batch production, means that supply often struggles to keep up. If you’re determined to find a bottle, persistence and patience will be your allies. Regularly check the distillery website, your local liquor stores, and secondary markets. You might just get lucky when a new batch is released or when inventory unexpectedly becomes available. With a bit of time and dedication, you’ll eventually find your prized bottle!

FAQs – Answering Common Questions About Barrell Bourbon

Barrell Bourbon has certainly made a name for itself by producing some of the most intriguing and delicious craft bourbons around. However, their unique blends and finishing techniques often lead to a few common questions. Let’s address some of them:

  • How does Barrell source their bourbon? Barrell purchases aged bourbon from reputable distilleries in Kentucky and Tennessee. They then take these carefully selected barrels to their facility in Louisville, where they expertly blend and finish them to create their distinctive Barrell expressions.
  • What type of barrels do they use to finish the bourbon? Barrell employs a diverse range of wine, rum, and other unique barrels to impart additional layers of flavor to their bourbons. Some examples include Cabernet, Pinot Noir, Madeira, Sauternes, and rum casks. Each type of finishing barrel contributes its own unique character to the final bourbon.
  • How long are the bourbons finished? The finishing periods at Barrell can vary, but they typically range from 3 to 18 months. Longer finishing times generally result in bourbons that exhibit more intense flavors derived from the finishing barrels.
  • Are Barrell’s bourbons chill-filtered? No, Barrell chooses not to chill-filter their bourbons. Chill-filtering, while it can improve clarity, can also strip away some of the natural flavor and color compounds. Barrell avoids this process to deliver a more robust and flavorful product. As a result, some bottles might contain harmless natural sediment.
  • Does Barrell produce any barrel-strength bourbons? Absolutely! Barrell offers several barrel-strength bourbon releases, typically ranging from around 120 to 130 proof. These uncut and unfiltered bourbons retain all the intense and concentrated flavors from the barrel, without any dilution from water. If you appreciate high-proof, flavorful bourbons, these are definitely worth exploring!

Final Thoughts

In summary, Barrell is a true innovator in the bourbon world, crafting a compelling line of bourbons through their unique blending and finishing techniques. Their diverse expressions offer a wide array of flavors for bourbon enthusiasts to discover and savor. If you have any further questions about Barrell’s production methods or their bourbon in general, be sure to check out their website or reach out to them on social media – they’re usually quite responsive and happy to share more details about their process!

Brian Daigle
Brian Daigle
Articles: 89

Newsletter Updates

Enter your email address below and subscribe to our newsletter